top of page
Search

The Hidden Costs of Poor Portfolio Management in EPC Project Lifecycles and How to Avoid Them 

Sep 17
5 min read

It's rare that a single decision causes a capital project to fail. Rather, value is lost more frequently because of poor portfolio decisions, conflicting priorities, resource conflicts, late approvals, and investments made beyond the business case.


Portfolio Management in EPC

These issues are costly in engineering, procurement, and construction. Inadequate portfolio governance results in schedule congestion, duplicated engineering and procurement, contractor conflicts and underutilized assets. Effective portfolio management assists leaders in determining which projects to invest in where and when.


Why Portfolio Blind Spots Persist


The project controls within engineering, procurement, and construction are well established. The project level is familiar with the following methods: Earned value analysis, critical path scheduling, and stage-gate reviews.

 

There is much less consistency at the portfolio level. Reporting may roll up financials but doesn't roll up capacity or risk correlation or decision sequencing. The program is healthy, and the stack of green dashboards is given to the sponsor.

 

Project Lifecycle Management is not just about having visibility inside the project, but across projects as well. If it is not installed, the following expenses are added.


Resource Dilution; Portfolio Management

Cost One: Resource Dilution


The shortest supply of a capital project is skilled manpower. Just like the above, senior process engineers, commissioning leads, and experienced construction managers are distributed throughout a portfolio, regardless of intent.

 

If each project has 60% of the same lead engineer, then no project gets 100%. Reviews get rushed. Until fabrication, interface issues are unknown. The rework ends up on the project that finds it, making a failure in the project staffing seem like a single project problem.

 

Cost Two: Capital Trapped in Sequencing Errors


The bulk of a project's final cost outcome is determined by the front-end budget, and the front-end budget for each project is bidding for discretionary funds on a portfolio.

 

When organizations are pressed, they tend to distribute the funding of definition opportunities over many opportunities instead of developing a few. What you end up with is a stream of half-scratchy scopes, none of which are able to confidently make their way to sanction. Capital is idle, and definition gaps remain, and the projects that are undertaken include assumptions that haven't been addressed in the work.


Cost Three: Lost Procurement Leverage


Project by project procurement is negotiated, and sacrifices scale. In many instances, three teams within the same organization purchase long-lead equipment like transformers, compressors, switchgear, and chillers at three different price levels in the same quarter.

 

In addition to price, the fragmented buying process results in inconsistent technical specifications, duplicated vendor qualification process, and vying claims on the same fabrication time. In a typical consolidated category strategy, there is significant value that is recovered in a portfolio that is lost when procurement remains siloed.


Cost Four: Correlated Risk Treated as Isolated


Project risk registers usually consider exposures locally. In practice, there is a close relationship between the risks of portfolios.

 

Multiple renewable projects may be limited by a single interconnection queue on the grid. Failure of one shipyard can impact several maritime assets. Construction sites have a regional shortage of labor. If these correlations go under the radar, contingency is sized for one-off events, and concentrated exposure happens without notice.

 

Correlated Risk Treated as Isolated

Cost Five: Knowledge That Never Travels


There are hard-wanted lessons that come from each project: a vendor that didn't go as planned, a modular approach that was successful, a permitting sequence that saved months.


If there is no governance to the portfolio, that knowledge remains within the team that created it. The following project is the same discovery at a full cost. A single lesson may be paid four or five times over a 5-year capital budget period.


Building a Portfolio That Performs


These costs are structural, meaning they are sensitive to structural changes. There are five consistent close to the gap practices.


  • Establish a single portfolio view


Normalize project schedule, cost, and risk information for easy comparison across projects without translation. Rather than complex software, common work breakdown structures and consistent progress definitions are more important. No dashboard will save an analysis if two different PMs report different percent complete. Begin with data that is used to inform decisions, then build up.

 

  • Apply stage gates as a portfolio filter


Capital allocation should be based on gates, not project progress. Ask at each gate, is this project a worthy use of funding and talent in comparison to all other projects? Finding the will to suspend a viable project in favor of a more promising one, and then disciplined project management, is where EPC comes in.

 

  • Plan capacity before making commitments


Have a rolling forecast of specialists available against the sanctioned and likely pipeline. Deliberately fill capacity gaps with strategy of resequencing, recruiting or contracting instead of discovering them at the starting point.

 

Manage risk at the portfolio level

  • Manage risk at the portfolio level


Create a shared risk register, incorporating project risk drivers, such as supply markets, regulatory authorities, labor supply, and interconnection authorities. Use size contingency for correlated exposure; consider concentration as a decision input for approving new work.

 

  • Choose delivery models that reduce interface load


Turnkey EPC solutions bring together design, procurement and construction responsibility, and decrease the coordination effort that the portfolio manager carries. For repeatable or standardized scope, this is not the right model, but for some scope it makes governance time available for truly complex tasks.


Sector Differences Matter


The dynamic of the portfolio is different across different industries. The high volume and moderate complexity of renewable energy programs are generally those in which repeatability and interconnection sequencing are important attributes to outcomes. Oil and gas portfolios have a lower number of larger projects where the coordination of turnaround windows and shutdowns contributes to value. The challenges for maritime programs are limited shipyard slots and classification demands. Power capacity and cooling systems are among the most competitive in data center builds, along with finding qualified electrical staff.

 

A bottom-up strategy will fail if it's a one-size-fits-all solution from another industry. Transfer of governance principles only, not specific constraints.

 

Conclusion: Take the Next Step

Take the Next Step


Hidden portfolio costs add up without making a big noise and are only likely to appear in the single project reporting after profit margins have been sliced. The quickest way to identify them will be to review governance, capacity planning, and gate discipline as part of a structured review of your capital program, before they become a permanent overhead.

 

To get the expert advice throughout the lifecycle of your EPC project, please schedule an appointment with Alga Processing LLC: https://www.algaprocessing.com/book-appointment


Alga Processing

Alga Processing LLC is an organization that helps your business in operations and management. Its people come from various backgrounds of knowledge and experience that promote a healthy environment for your personnel. Your organization will benefit from ensuring you and your team members are there every day to give the time and talent to yield productivity to its maximum. Contact us for more information on how to help your business grow.

 
 
 

Comments


logo-apllc-right- large size  (1)_edited_edited.png

Copyright by Alga Processing LLC

bottom of page